Replacement Windows: A Complete Buying Guide

Buying replacement windows comes down to a handful of decisions: how the windows will be installed, what the frames are made of, which styles you need, how they perform for your climate, and who will do the work. This guide walks through each one and links to our detailed guides.

Signs It May Be Time To Replace

Lowe’s lists drafty rooms, chipped or damaged frames, and more outside noise coming in as common signs. If the frames are sound and the problem is drafts or noise, an insert or film may be a cheaper fix; see the alternatives below.

Full-Frame Vs. Insert (Pocket) Replacement

MethodWhat Is RemovedWhen It Fits
Insert (pocket)The old sashes and hardware; the existing frame, sill and trim stayThe existing frame is square, solid and free of rot
Full-frameThe whole window, including the frame and trim, back to the rough openingThe frame or surrounding wood is damaged, or you want to inspect the opening

Insert installation takes less labor and time. Full-frame installation costs more and takes longer, but lets the installer find and repair rot or water damage. Pella notes that a pocket window is only as efficient as the installation of the existing frame it sits in. Ask every installer which method the quote assumes.

Frame Materials

MaterialWhat To Know
VinylAffordable and low maintenance; Renewal by Andersen notes vinyl can bend or bow over time
Wood and clad woodWood interiors can be painted or stained; clad windows protect the exterior with aluminum, vinyl or fiberglass
FiberglassGenerally more expensive, low maintenance and long lasting
CompositeBlends materials; Andersen’s Fibrex combines wood fiber and polymer
AluminumThin frames and large glass areas; suits modern designs

Window Styles

Match the style to the room: ventilation, cleaning, egress and space outside all matter. Our types of windows guide compares 12 styles, from double-hung and casement to bay, garden and hopper windows.

Energy Efficiency

ENERGY STAR sets window requirements by climate zone, based on ratings certified by the National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC). Compare the U-factor (lower keeps more heat in) and solar heat gain coefficient (lower blocks more summer sun) on each window’s NFRC label.

Sizes And Measuring

Replacement windows are usually made to the measured opening. See our standard window sizes chart for common dimensions by type, and have the installer confirm final measurements.

Cost

Price depends on the frame material, size, glass, style, installation method and the condition of the opening. Our window replacement cost guide breaks down the price drivers.

Who Sells And Installs Replacement Windows

Pella lists four ways to get windows installed: a manufacturer’s showroom, an independent contractor, a home improvement store, or doing it yourself. Our replacement window companies guide compares full-service companies, home centers and manufacturers.

Bedroom Egress

If a window serves as a bedroom’s emergency escape opening, the replacement must still meet the minimum opening size. See our egress window guide.

Alternatives To Replacement

More Buying Guides

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Difference Between Insert And Full-Frame Replacement?

An insert window fits inside the existing frame, which stays in place. A full-frame replacement removes the old frame and trim and installs a complete new window.

What Is The Best Replacement Window Material?

There is no single best. Vinyl is affordable and low maintenance, fiberglass and composite are durable, and wood or clad wood offers the most traditional look.

How Do I Know If My Windows Need Replacing?

Drafty rooms, chipped or damaged frames and more outside noise are common signs.

Sources